Waterman Farm: A Saltwater Legacy on North Haven
Set on 177± acres of exceptional island landscape, Waterman Farm offers spectacular panoramic views to the south and east towards the Fox Island Thorofare and out towards Penobscot Bay. Perched on a secluded point of land, this classic saltwater farm features 8,582± feet of shorefront with access to both the protected Cubby Hole and Waterman Cove. The quintessential island setting is stunning, with over 40± acres of open fields, areas of woods, gardens, orchards, and five historic and distinguished residences. The property includes a dock with a ramp and float on Waterman Cove, a gateway to world-class boating around the island, on the Fox Island Thorofare, and Penobscot Bay. Waterman Farm’s significant and continuous acreage presents a rare opportunity to own a true piece of North Haven’s legacy.
The current owners have been excellent and thoughtful stewards of the property. Hailing from Maine, and the founders of a successful shoe company based in Texas, the family has continued to nurture their strong connection to Maine through a sensitive and thorough rehabilitation of the farm. The buildings and the landscape have been meticulously restored, paying tribute to the island’s farming heritage. Using timber milled from trees harvested right on the land, processed in a sawmill built by the family, every beam, board, and frame was milled with care. Attention to historic detail is evident in every element — from hand-hewn finishes to careful preservation of original architecture — blending uncompromised authenticity with quiet luxury.
Now, five restored residences, all in excellent condition, are scattered across the property, offering privacy and comfort in the most idyllic island setting. Additional estate infrastructure includes a historic barn, a sawmill and a Quonset hut, contributing to the versatility of the property. Suitable for agricultural pursuits, residential living, or a family compound, Waterman Farm offers an extraordinary opportunity to own one of Maine’s most iconic waterfront estates.
The Big House (c. 1780)
- This historic, fully restored farmhouse radiates timeless simplicity. Original wood paneling, plaster walls, wide-board floors and exposed beams come together with historic fireplaces and period paint colors to create lasting appeal.
- Charming “lobster room” entry with a large table and sink – perfect for hosting traditional, family lobster dinners
- Gourmet kitchen with professional appliances, Maine slate countertops and a farmhouse sink
- Dining area, central living room and multiple historic fireplaces, second-floor den/living room
- Three bedrooms, two full baths
Beach House
- Timber-frame construction with cathedral great room, warm rustic finishes
- Two bedrooms, two full baths
- Deck with expansive Waterman Cove views
Carriage House (c. 1780)
- Preserved original hand-hewn beams. Historic pegs that once held equipment are still visible
- Open kitchen and living area
- Two bedrooms, one full bath
Caretaker’s House
- Timber-frame design with an open kitchen, living and dining space, and a loft
- Central chimney: wood stove on one side, fireplace on the other
- Two bedrooms, two full baths
Pig Pen / Pool House
- Compact and cozy: kitchen/living room with woodstove
- One bedroom, one bath
Barn (c. 1780)
- Original structure in very good condition
- Raised and set on a new stone wall foundation with new barn doors
Quonset Hut
- Historically used for lumber storage
- Currently used for farm equipment and workshop
Sawmill
- Operational design: logs roll into cutting station, milled in stages
- A piece of island history — once used by local residents to mill lumber
Property Features
- Multiple sheds/outbuildings for storage or farm use
- Organic gardens and a fenced orchard – highly productive
- Over 40± acres of open fields
- Well-maintained trail leading to the Cubby Hole
- Well-maintained woods, original stone walls, and trail systems
- Direct trail access to conservation land, golf course, and village
- Dock with 3–4 ft depth at low tide, 11–12 ft in cove (mud bottom), one substantial mooring